top of page

Is anything fair in Love and War?

Writer: Nabeeha KhanNabeeha Khan

Have you ever sat down and compared how you would never pursue such a love interest if you were to be in the movie you are watching? Or how your real love life and demands may greatly differ from what is shown on TV or in film?


These movies tend to exaggerate the crazy love feeling, of course for the benefit of entertainment, but also regardless lets many ideas of respect, boundaries, and other issues loose.


Many crime genre films and shows are now set around love, not taking revenge or a love triangle, but a crime to express the great heights of possessiveness or jealousy. Many

famous examples include You, Gone Girl, etc. This is feeding into viewers' brains that toxic obsession, social media stalking, and 'removing obstacles' are justified in the name of love. And while I agree that lately, many movies speak about issues like domestic violence like "Thappad", many of them don't get as much hype as the problematic ones.


Other issues like reinforcing gender norms, stereotypes about masculinity and femininity, the concept of marriage and freedom and how it differs for each gender, the evil in-laws, etc are prevalent in almost all romance.



Even when we do not relate to the movie e.g. Kissing Booth, it was trending on Netflix for a long time. Movies like Kabir Singh and Animal that have received great backlash were both blockbusters. So do viewers like some level of toxicity or unrelatableness to be able to enjoy a film?



Would we love to be kidnapped and forced to fall in love with someone, or does it satisfy some sort of hidden pleasures of people that 365 Days became one of the most-watched movies in Pakistan? Perhaps it is due to the late average age of marriage and

the religious and cultural environment in Pakistan that such raunchy movies never flop, but any movie like 'Joyland' is quick to be termed as "fahashi" or the influence of

the West. Therefore, highlighting the clear bias between heterosexual romance and intimacy vs any homosexual tendencies.


Even though social media platforms are raising awareness of toxic behaviors and 'red flags' in a relationship, the media depiction of these issues is failing to catch up. Perhaps because we as an audience do not want to watch them, and this is a profit-seeking industry after all.



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

22 Comments


Wali Hassan
Wali Hassan
Jun 30, 2024

The blog post acuurately looks at how movies and TV shows often show love and relationships in unrealistic and harmful ways, making it hard to tell the difference between fiction and reality. These exaggerated portrayals can ignore important aspects of healthy relationships, like respect and boundaries. It mentions how some shows, like "You" and movies like "Gone Girl," mix crime with love, showing possessiveness and jealousy in a dramatic way that might make viewers think stalking and obsession are normal. The blog also points out that many films reinforce old-fashioned ideas about gender roles, affecting how people see men and women, marriage, and freedom. Despite being controversial, movies like "Kabir Singh" and "365 Days" are popular, suggesting that viewers might…

Like
Nabeeha Khan
Nabeeha Khan
Jun 30, 2024
Replying to

I see that you have understood and agreed with all my points. I am glad I was able to clearly convey my perspective.

Like

26020447
Jun 30, 2024

This post hit hard! It's interesting how movies and shows can blur the lines between acceptable and toxic behavior. Take the telefilm "Roohposh," for instance. It was trending on YouTube for so long, and the hero, who was clearly a red flag, ended up being admired by many. Similarly, Danish Taimoor's character in the drama "Dewangi" harassed and crossed boundaries of the female protagonist, yet the drama was a super hit.

This brings to light an important point: toxic masculinity isn't just a male issue. Many females also admire such characters, which influences their real-life experiences and makes them more likely to fall for such men. The media plays a powerful role in shaping our perspectives on who is a…

Like
Nabeeha Khan
Nabeeha Khan
Jun 30, 2024
Replying to

Thank you for your insights, I love other examples you have brought up, I haven't seen them but I will definitely look into them. I agree that it is also that women like these characters that they continued to be produced over and over world wide. I hope that CML becomes more and more popular so that the audience can be more mindful of the media they consume and maybe one day we will see a shift from romanticizing such characters and men in real life.

Like

Amna Shahzad
Jun 28, 2024

I really like how your blog post provides valuable insight regarding how media provide particular frame when it comes to the concept of Love. As you mentioned, there are many movies highlighting toxic behaviors that are justified in war of love, but we still neglect to look at particular audiences these movies are targeting. Movies like 365 days or Kabir Singh are targeting young adults perhaps in age 20s or 30s who are delved into controversial romantic relationships and support it. These movies also reflect the cultural context of their designed country. Kabir Singh reflects Indian societal norms where we see such relations previaling a lot while 365 Days highlights European tradition with some thriller element. I think it is…

Like
Nabeeha Khan
Nabeeha Khan
Jun 30, 2024
Replying to

I totally agree that the audience and producers are very important to critically analyze these media products. However the problem is that people do not get to pick and choose what they deem religiously acceptable and not because if that was the sole reason of these bans, toxic movies of normalizing cheating and domestic violence should also have been met with the same fate as Joyland.

Like

Your blog is very insightful and talks about some very important topics that deserve more attention. The fact that movies and shows that romantic toxic love and misogyny is deeply concerning. What makes this worse is the lack of critical media literacy that exists in Pakistan and how reactions to media are more protectionist than preparatory. These movies can be seen by those who are too young to watch them and because of the lack of CML, this creates unhealthy perceptions of love not only for girls but also men who watch them. They think this toxic behavior is what it means to show love which is very problematic and can become very scary. The contrast you draw between films…


Like
Nabeeha Khan
Nabeeha Khan
Jun 30, 2024
Replying to

Thank you for your insights on the topic. I think that coining a place progressive is a very surface level thing. How can one really term a place as progressive you know? What people are at home vs outside is very different. Many people may be more accepting now of others but would prefer the 'traditional' for themselves. I think it is again stereotypes that show working class as having such societal problems, however, it is just a lack of representation that leads us to believe so.

Like

Rida Salman
Rida Salman
Jun 28, 2024

Your blog raises essential questions about the media’s role in shaping our understanding of love and relationships. You raise some interesting and thought-provoking concerns - questioning whether viewers enjoy toxicity and current representations in the media. Your incorporation of Pakistan's cultural background has also effectively added to what you've expressed. The contrast between how films like "365 Days" and "Joyland" were received in our country provides a nuanced view of how societal attitudes and cultural conventions influence media consumption and romantic perspectives. It makes me wonder first who the target audience for movies like "365 Days" and "Kabir Singh" is - is it the men? but so many of the viewers are women, and so moving on to my second question - why do women find the men in…

Like
Nabeeha Khan
Nabeeha Khan
Jun 30, 2024
Replying to

I remember seeing many posts on social media and im sure you must have too which has pictures of problematic characters looking all "hot" with serious expressions, very strong, intelligent and "masculine", and the caption says "i blame movies for my toxic taste in men". I think that while many women may be unaware that these men are toxic as this is what they have seen since forever in their surrounding. However, many are aware, but find them attractive. Perhaps just for entertainment and to imagine being a mafia boss' wife for the thrill of it. But my explanation is in context with the stereotype again that women like being submissive. I find myself in a loophole for what may…

Like
Post: Blog2_Post

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2020 by EDU 274: Media Policy Project. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page