top of page

Tare Zameen par: Does everyone find their Raam?


Agha has the same disability as the star Kid!

While watching an Indian Film, "Tare Zameen Par," my 15-year-old cousin shouted this sentence for his 12-year-old brother.

For a moment, I was stunned to listen to this, and ultimately, my focus shifted toward the film's theme. The film depicts an 8-year-old boy Ishan with the mental illness "dyslexia," i.e., a Learning disability in processing words and numbers, who eventually comes under the guardian of an unconventional art teacher "Raam," and overcomes his disability to function properly in a boarding school. Hearing those words hedged my mind with multiple thoughts about whether every student in Pakistan finds their Raam? are there any international or governmental efforts done to cater to the educational needs of such students in Pakistan? or are they left all alone at the mercy of their fates?. Thus, my curiosity led me to research; hence, below are some of these questions' findings.


According to the World Bank Report on Disability in 2019, the ratio of disabled students in Pakistan is 3.56% of the total population. Due to the lack of constitutional support in identifying the issue, there are many discrepancies in providing an apparent ratio of mentally and physically disabled students in Pakistan.

While on the other hand, there had been very minimal efforts on a governmental basis to cater educational needs of such students.


The detailed research enlisted only two programs the Government of Pakistan implemented to educate these students. The first incorporated into Punjab was named "The Punjab Educational Program," which provides educational (free textbooks, braille books, pick & drop, monthly stipend, skill development, and training courses) and rehabilitative services (physiotherapy, speech therapy, and play therapy) to such students. While the second one was established by the government of Sindh, named as Center for Autism Rehabilitation and Training (C-ART), which is responsible for providing free-of-charge education to autistic children in Karachi and Hyderabad. Except for these two rest of the provinces of Pakistan sufficiently lack mechanisms to provide educational support to students with disabilities.

Secondly, the question of whether every student finds their raam?, elaborates over the purpose that at what level in Pakistan parents and teachers are aware of this issue and to what extent they struggle to become Raam of their children/students. According to the research, cultural stigmatization of students with mental disabilities varies based on the socio-cultural and economic aspects of those students, parents, and teachers. However, to a greater extent, such students have been prone to cultural stigmatization and discrimination. Moreover, if there is minimal awareness about such issues between teachers or parents, there have been no training or guidelines provided by the government to educate them about facilitation ways to cater educational needs of such students.


In order to not nullify the minimal steps taken by the government of Pakistan to help students with disabilities, it would be sufficient to say that the government has started giving attention to the stated issue. However, there needs to be more detailed research, policy-making, and implementation to support such students completely. UNICEF's report "Disability-Inclusive Education Practices in Pakistan" provides the below-mentioned recommendation to the Government of Pakistan to build a proper mechanism to help disabled students.

  1. To strengthen coordination mechanisms.

  2. To conduct a review of financing and funding mechanisms.

  3. To assess the monitoring and evaluation systems in place.

  4. Make sure funds are allocated for inclusive strategies for educating students with disabilities.

  5. Strengthen professional development assistance for disabled students at schools.

  6. Examine pre-service and in-service teacher preparation.

  7. Create policies and procedures to deal with violence in schools.

  8. To assess the implementation of laws and policies on disability-inclusive education.

  9. To assess how the Minimum Standards for Quality Education are used in schools.

To conclude, it has become non-negligible for the government of Pakistan to take necessary actions and for parents and teachers to adopt unconventional ways to become "raam" of these exceptional students so they do not fail to achieve their purposes only due to never-worthy ignomies or insufficient policies.


31 views3 comments

3 Comments


This posts reminds me of my friend back in middle school who had ADHD and everyone else would make fun of her and most of the teachers also would call her out loudly to pay attention and listen carefully in class because then she always ends up failing. Most of the other girls would take advantage of her desperateness to make friends by asking her to treat them. Her mother had a contract with the canteen uncle to note dow whatever she takes and wants and she would clear the bill all together at the end of the month. She belonged to a pretty rich family so slowly she started making some friends just so that they would hangout together.…

Like

The film Taare Zameen Par by Amir Khan inspired me to look into learning disabilities in children that may easily get passed off as them just misbehaving and choosing not to listen. In this film, the main character Ishaan is an 8-year-old boy who is considered lazy and a troublemaker who shows no interest in school. At first, you just assume that he is just a naughty boy who would rather do his own thing than listen to any adult. Due to a patient and compassionate teacher, you find out that Ishaan suffers from dyslexia. He does not pay attention in school because he simply does not understand the language or numbers. In his mind, the words in front of…

Like
Replying to

Indeed an insightful comment Zeeshan!

When my cousin shouted this about his brother, more than being shocked, I felt resentment towards the Lil lad as it was something granted to him by nature which is undoubtedly an undefendable pursuit for him; however, analyzing the socio-cultural context of south Asia and especially our surroundings, I figured it out that people stigmatize such things due to lack of basic awareness related to mental health problem. Moreover, medical upgradation has always been slower in our region, and more emphasis has been given to more physical or, to say, apparent diseases, and ultimately the cure has been found. There is an urgent need for an awareness campaign to make people aware of mental issues…


Like
Post: Blog2_Post
bottom of page